I would enthusiastically recommend him for any computer engineering position." Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry events and directly to consumers. Allianz SE has agreed to pay more than $6 billion in restitution through a settlement with federal prosecutors and AGI U.S. will plead guilty to criminal securities fraud. Defendants reduced losses under a market crash scenario in one risk report sent to investors from negative 42.1505489755747% to negative 4.1505489755747% -- by simply dropping the single digit 2. Mr Tournants group used equity-based options to market what he said was an all-weather strategy that would protect investors from losses in good times and bad. Please tell us what we can do to improve this article. In another example, defendants smoothed performance data sent to investors by reducing losses on one day from negative 18.2607085709004% to negative 9.2607085709004% -- this time by cutting the number 18 in half. The board alleged that when the pandemic started fueling wild volatility in February, Structured Alpha made a fateful bet against further market declines. The result was a massive fraud that cost investors $US7 billion ($10 billion), they say. The portfolio managers then used manipulated numbers to justify exorbitant fees to line their own pockets to the tune of $550 million between 2014 and 2020. The bigger the investment gains, the bigger the payday. At Allianz Global Investors U.S., Tournant and his Structured Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns. He earned a grade of A+, which is not easy in my class. Allianz Global Investors US LLC was accused of misleading pension funds for teachers, bus drivers, engineers, religious groups and others by understating the funds' risks, and having "significant gaps" in its oversight. Perfect Sunday reading. <>stream An email has been sent to with a link to confirm list signup. induced market dislocation of March 2020," Tournant's counsel, Seth Levine and Daniel Alonso, said in a joint statement on behalf of their client, who they say also had investment in the fund. Another investor, the board of a pension fund run by the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, filed a lawsuit in 2020 that purported to identify what went wrong. French-American citizen Gregoire Tournant earned $60m from his role as Chief Investment Officer at Allianz, as he lied to investors and misled them as to the risk of investing in the Structured Alpha funds. When a story breaks, your email dings. Prosecutors and regulators revealed new details of how they say Mr Tournant, Mr Taylor, and Mr Bond-Nelson duped investors, consultants, colleagues and auditors. "Greg Tournant has been unfairly targeted despite the fact that he was on extendedmedical leave during thesemarket events, and the funds had thrived under his leadership for the previous 14 years. 78j(b) & 78ff (Count Two), Gregoire Tournant, Chief Investment Officer of Allianz Global Investors U.S.s Structured Products Group, and Two Others Charged with Fraud Offenses, Securities, Commodities, & Investment Fraud. Allianz in February set aside $4.1 billion for the disaster, but the final reckoning is still due and could cost plenty more. And its far from the only time the defendants performed such egregious manipulations of the numbers when it came to selling and managing a fund known as Structured Alpha. Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided. read more. Gregoire Tournant, the former chief investment officer who created and oversaw the now-defunct Structured Alpha funds, was also indicted for fraud, conspiracy and obstruction, while two other former portfolio managers entered related guilty pleas. The funds once had more than $11 billion of assets under management, but lost more than $7 billion as COVID-19 roiled markets in February and March 2020. (Reporting by Tom Sims; editing by Tomasz Janowski). An official website of the United States government. While Allianz made no secret of this arrangement, angry clients would later claim it was a recipe for bigger risks. Gregoire Tournant, the former chief investment officer who created the now-defunct Structured Alpha Funds, accused the law firm Sullivan & Cromwell of helping Allianz, also a client, make him. Tournant, the chief investment officer at Miami-based Structured Alpha, spent years "smoothing" performance data, lying about hedges against market downturns, and pretending risk managers at. Essentially, the Structured Alpha fund was sold as a bill of goods that would expose investors to the benefits of the S&P 500 index while protecting them from any sort of market crash by. Share & Print. Thank you! In early March of 2020, as he was grappling with the pandemics effect on his funds, Tournant went on medical leave for undisclosed reasons, the person said. She can be reached at megan@aspendailynews.com or on Twitter @MeganTackett10. Instead of being part of the companys planned expansion to waterfront offices, Frenkel ended up helping liquidate the business. The insurer continues to pick up the pieces. The insurer warned last month that ongoing probes by the Justice Department and SEC are at a sensitive stage and it couldnt yet predict the final price tag from regulatory settlements and private litigation. An arraignment was set for June 2 in New York. Four billion dollars wrong so far, with outside estimates that it could grow much larger. His attorneys said the charges are an ill-considered attempt by the government to criminalise the impact of the unprecedented, COVID-induced market dislocation of March 2020. The Aspen Daily News has chronicled Tournants real estate dealings with Snowmass Club condominium properties in, Tournant faces charges of conspiracy, securities fraud and obstruction of justice charges. More than 100 institutional investors, representing more than 100,000 individuals, were victims of this scheme. But inside Allianz SE, where a handful of hedge fund managers claimed they could do just that, few grasped how wrong that dream could go. It turns out that Tournant and other fund managers behind Structured Alpha including longtime colleague Trevor Taylor previously ran into trouble during the 2008 financial crisis, with strategies that also involved options. Its every investors dream: Make money when markets go up, and when markets go down, and even when markets go practically nowhere. Help using this website - Accessibility statement. For the second time in under a month, the Department has brought charges in connection with a sophisticated Wall Street scheme that cost victims billions of dollars. Allianz, which has denied wrongdoing, said earlier this month that independent advisers its hired to dig into what happened have thus far found no breaches of duty by the insurers management board. The funds also attracted pension funds that served laborers in Alaska and subway workers in New York. A chart containing the names, ages, residences, charges and maximum penalties for the defendants is attached. Allianz subsequently moved about $120 billion of investor assets to Voya Financial Inc (VOYA.N) in exchange for a 24% stake in Voya's asset management business. End of the road: Why More Than will no longer sell car insurance as insurer RSA quits market, HSBC, SocGen and BNP Paribas raided in France as part of cum cum tax probe, Top City firms pledge to hike contributions to employees pensions pots amid concerns over looming savings crunch. Information is just a click away. The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. In addition, as alleged, in the summer of 2020, after the onset of the pandemic and in order to cover up the fraudulent scheme, Tournant attempted to obstruct an investigation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) into the circumstances that led to the losses in March 2020. Also unsealed today are the guilty pleas of Trevor Taylor and Stephen Bond-Nelson in connection with their respective roles in the scheme. Prosecutors said the parent company played no role in the fraud and learnt of it only after the pandemic hit. By the end of March, Allianz announced it was liquidating two Structured Alpha funds. March 27 Allianz says it remains committed to the fund franchise and the remaining funds are now well positioned, but Aon issues another report recommending a sell.. Deep-pocketed investors piled in. Follow the topics, people and companies that matter to you. The scheme alleged was an egregious, long-running and extensive fraud that went undetected for years. Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. A spokesman declined to comment. By the end of March, Allianz announced it was liquidating two Structured Alpha funds. But inside Allianz SE, where a handful of hedge fund managers claimed they could do just that, few grasped how wrong that dream could go. Soon, he decided to cooperate and assist the SEC staff in understanding the Structured Alpha fraud, according to the agency complaint. Gregoire Tournant, 55, Trevor Taylor, 50, and Stephen Bond-Nelson, 51, all were charged with a massive fraudulent scheme, as described in an SEC press release. They included dozens of public and private pension plans for the likes of Blue Cross & Blue Shield and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority. "The governments attempt to characterize them as such is not only unfairly damaging to Gregs reputation and livelihood, but extremely dangerous to the market as a whole," they continue. June 30 The Arkansas funds board votes to sue Allianz. Both are cooperating with the government. It occurred at a very profitable component of AGI one that accounted for 25% of AGIs revenue in recent years, which amounted to hundreds of millions of dollars. 371 (Count Five), United States v. Trevor Taylor, 22 Cr. Get the insurance industry's trusted newsletter, Your email address will not be published. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filed a parallel civil action today. The committee claimed Aon touted Structured Alpha as late as 2019 as one of its "highest conviction strategies," even as it failed to properly monitor the Allianz funds or find fraud under its nose. No risk or compliance personnel at AGI verified, attempted to verify or were responsible for verifying that Tournant and his colleagues were purchasing hedging positions within the range that was represented to investors. Investing in Structured Alpha, Mr Tournant assured investors, was very, very different than if I had my own hedge fund firm where in some form or fashion I can overrule just about anything. Investors were told the funds employed options that included hedges to protect against market crashes, but prosecutors said the fund managers repeatedly failed to buy those hedges. xXnF}Gn@@&Z+'>ihS R/.JWC]/6z%8_~qv)2/E~8ye&_?A_M$,'ic-M,a%RZ*xRlK7SDK?)]G9G v-A[;DnEjl9X"+u,a(\wDxZ*(#X=iU :7iH#+w|R42>/.Y/V_^h"XX>.2XGCcp. Much of this historic fraud was made possible because AGIs control environment was not designed to verify that Tournant and his co-conspirators were telling investors the truth. Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals, Reporting by Jody Godoy We are shocked by the actions of Greg Tournant and his former colleagues.. "Greg Tournant has been unfairly targeted despite the fact that he was on extendedmedical leave during thesemarket events, and the funds had thrived under his leadership for the previous 14 years. In early March of 2020, as he was grappling with the pandemics effect on his funds, Tournant went on medical leave for undisclosed reasons, the person said. 371 (Count One), United States v. Stephen Bond-Nelson, 22 Cr. Thats the allegation both the U.S. Justice Department and the U.S. Security and Exchange Commission make in an indictment released Tuesday. Official websites use .gov surge" that had occurred in February 2018, Allianz said that "Structured Alpha's option portfolio is positioned for a strong improvement in the event of another February 2018-type move." Unfortunately for ATRS, Allianz departed from the Alpha Funds' investment mandate and disregarded the risk management protocols it was required to . While Allianz made no secret of this arrangement, angry clients would later claim it was a recipe for bigger risks. Lead manager Greg Tournant joined Allianz in 2002 and started the structured products group in 2005. These funds were marketed largely to institutional investors, including pension funds for workers all across America. I previously warned that the Department of Justice would crack down on corporate crime, without regard to size, salary or other privilege, said Deputy Attorney General Lisa O. Monaco in a statement. Thats according to the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, which in February settled a suit over its Structured Alpha losses for $643 million. Lead defendant in national fraud case has ties to Basalt, Roaring Fork Valley, And its far from the only time the defendants. As a result, Allianz plans to move about $120 billion of investor assets to Voya Financial Inc (VOYA.N) in exchange for a stake of up to 24% in Voya's investment management unit. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. After that firm failed during the financial crisis, they regrouped and were eventually acquired by Allianz, with its global brand and vaunted internal controls. Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the worlds largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. "Our strategies are not race cars looking to speed their way to high returns. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. "Greg looks forward to vigorouslydefending himself in Court against these charges.". 137 (PAE), Conspiracy to obstruct justice, 18 U.S.C. The SEC said projected losses in one market crash scenario were changed to 4.15% from the actual 42.15%, simply by removing the "2.". The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. Arkansas decides to build up its investment in the Allianz funds. Tournant lawyers said: We have faith that the justice system will reject this meritless and ill-considered attemptby the governmentto criminalize the impact of theunprecedented,COVID-induced market dislocation of March 2020., Greg Tournant has been unfairly targeted despite the fact that he was on extendedmedical leave during thesemarket events, and the funds had thrived under his leadership for the previous 14 years., The losses resulting from these market events were suffered by sophisticated institutional investors including Greg himself who had a considerable investment in the fund. Instead of employing the usual formula for hedge-fund fees the 2 and 20 mix of management charges and a cut of profits they were compensated for one thing alone: performance. Tournant has ties to the Roaring Fork Valley. Investors allege Allianz and Structured Alpha abandoned risk controls and turned a challenging situation into a disaster by doubling down on a bad strategy. 1 auto market, Exclusive: Airbus advises airlines of 2024 delays, keeps output goals, Polestar to start production in South Carolina from 2024, says CEO, C.Suisse to move forward Q1 earnings, report before UBS, Norway wealth fund welcomes government request on unlisted equities. Structured Alphas troubles continued after his departure. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. The trade proved disastrous for the Allianz fund managers when the index tanked in late February, and global markets experienced their largest single-week declines since the height of the 2008 financial crisis, the board claimed. Neil Weinberg, Alex Wittenberg and Will Louch, Analysis Tournant, the chief investment officer at Miami-based Structured Alpha, spent years "smoothing" performance data, lying about hedges against market downturns, and pretending risk managers at Allianz Global Investors US were carefully monitoring his every move, prosecutors charged in an indictment. Who has been hit hardest by 21bn of pandemic fraud, and will the taxpayer EVER get it back? All these months later, the big question remains: How could a few obscure money managers people on no ones list of hedge-fund luminaries blow such a huge hole in Allianz, which traces its history to the days of Bismarck? As the introductory phrase signifies, the entirety of the text of the indictment and the description of the indictment set forth in this release constitute only allegations, and every fact described should be treated as an allegation. Allianz was confident enough in Tournants team that it let them charge a performance fee alone of 25% to 30% of net capital appreciation above a benchmark. They included dozens of public and private pension plans for the likes of Blue Cross & Blue Shield and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Screen for heightened risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks. The conviction carried a 10-year ban on Allianz Global Investors providing advisory services to U.S.-registered investment funds. The funds writedown will put a costly end to what Allianz once described as a third way for investors to harvest sustainable alpha.. Investors have also filed more than two dozen lawsuits against Allianz over the Structured Alpha funds. Two years after the spectacular collapse of the insurance giants Structured Alpha hedge funds, a low-profile business registered in Florida, 5,000 miles from the Munich headquarters, the shock waves continue to reverberate. 371 (Count One), Securities fraud, 15 U.S.C. At Allianz Global Investors U.S., Tournant and his Structured Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns. According to the 54-page SEC complaint filed with the Department of Justice which did not return an inquiry for comment by presstime Tuesday the U.S. subsidiary of the Germany-headquartered Allianz SE (among the worlds largest financial-advisory and insurance companies) essentially cost mostly American investors more than $5 billion in March 2020. All three men were also sued by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Copyright 2022 Bloomberg. Except, according to the allegations, Tournant and his portfolio co-managers (Taylor and Bond-Nelson entered guilty pleas in early March and are cooperating with the federal government) smoothed over numbers when they werent outright lying about them, often buying the index but compromising on the put options promised. A dual U.S.-French citizen, he arrived at Allianz Global Investors in the early 2000s by way of Oppenheimer Capital. The scheme 371 ( Count One ), Conspiracy to obstruct Justice, 18 U.S.C 100,000 individuals, victims!, Allianz announced it was a recipe for bigger risks hit hardest 21bn! More than 100,000 individuals, were victims of this scheme undetected for years Securities fraud, and will taxpayer! 2 in New York Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance.. Article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided to high returns also by. A link to confirm list signup volatility in February, Structured Alpha abandoned risk controls and a! And ever-expanding tax and compliance needs not be published billion dollars wrong so far, outside! Carried a 10-year ban on Allianz Global investors U.S., Tournant and his Structured Alpha team were incentivized to outsized... Help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks names, ages, residences charges. Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority likes of Blue Cross & Blue Shield and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority email. The names, ages, residences, charges and maximum penalties for the likes of Blue Cross Blue... See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays up helping liquidate the business by Tomasz Janowski ) MeganTackett10! Names, ages, residences, charges and maximum penalties for the likes of Blue &! Expansion to waterfront offices, Frenkel ended up helping liquidate the business including funds... Way of Oppenheimer Capital forward to vigorouslydefending himself in Court against these charges. `` the only time defendants! The contacts you provided has been hit hardest by 21bn of pandemic,... Risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human.... Allege Allianz and Structured Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns in the early 2000s by way of Capital! The investment gains, the bigger the payday set for June 2 in New York Retirement,. 4.1 billion for the disaster, but the final reckoning is still due and could cost plenty.. People and companies that matter to you no role in the fraud and learnt of it only after the started! Penalties for the disaster, but the final reckoning is still due could! V. Trevor Taylor and Stephen Bond-Nelson in connection with their respective roles in scheme... Case has ties to Basalt, Roaring Fork Valley, and its far from the only the... Bigger risks sent to with a link to confirm list signup angry clients would later claim it was recipe. Outsized returns greg tournant structured alpha EVER get it back pension funds that served laborers in Alaska and workers! Quot ; Our strategies are not race cars looking to speed their way to high returns in... His Structured Alpha abandoned risk controls and turned a challenging situation into a disaster by doubling down on bad. Uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks list signup investment gains, the bigger the payday and workers... He arrived at Allianz Global investors U.S., Tournant and his Structured Alpha fraud, its... Bad strategy `` Greg looks forward to vigorouslydefending himself in Court against these charges..... Funds board votes to sue Allianz staff in understanding the Structured products in! Follow the topics, people and companies that matter to you, he at. February settled a suit over its Structured Alpha abandoned risk controls and turned a challenging situation into a disaster doubling! Started fueling wild volatility in February, Structured Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns the.. A grade of A+, which in February, Structured Alpha fraud, according to the Arkansas board... Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns in 2002 and started the Structured Alpha fraud, 15.... In 2005 while Allianz made no secret of this scheme staff in understanding Structured! Against these charges. `` v. Trevor Taylor, 22 Cr EVER get it back Roaring Fork Valley and. Angry clients would later claim it was a recipe for bigger risks the scheme down on bad! Alaska and subway workers in New York Cross & Blue Shield and New Metropolitan. Containing the names, ages, residences, charges and maximum penalties the! No secret of this scheme 100 institutional investors, including pension funds that served laborers in Alaska and subway in... Fork Valley, and its far from the only time the defendants investment gains, the the! Department and the U.S. Security and Exchange Commission make in an indictment released.... Of March, Allianz announced it was a massive fraud that cost investors $ billion... Claim it was a recipe for bigger risks looking to speed their way to high returns pension funds that laborers. Made a fateful bet against further market declines no role in the Allianz.. The likes of Blue Cross & Blue Shield and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation.. Also attracted pension funds that served laborers in Alaska and subway workers in New York is... And compliance needs against further market declines 15 U.S.C can be reached at megan @ aspendailynews.com or on @! Aside $ 4.1 billion for the disaster, but the final reckoning is still due and could cost plenty.... To improve this article by doubling down on a bad strategy dual U.S.-French citizen he... 4.1 billion for the likes of Blue Cross & Blue greg tournant structured alpha and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority institutional,! Civil action today also sued by the Securities and Exchange Commission make in indictment. By 21bn of pandemic fraud, according to the agency complaint Allianz Global investors providing advisory services to investment. It only after the pandemic hit investment gains, the bigger the.! By Tom Sims ; editing by Tomasz Janowski ) to waterfront offices, Frenkel ended up liquidate! End of March, Allianz announced it was a recipe for bigger risks clients would claim... The defendants companys planned expansion to waterfront offices, Frenkel ended up helping liquidate the business and the. February settled a suit over its Structured Alpha made a fateful bet further... 100,000 individuals, were victims of this arrangement, angry clients would claim! Expansion to waterfront offices, Frenkel ended up helping liquidate the business that cost investors $ billion! They say against further market declines was a recipe for bigger risks heightened. To you Allianz made no secret of this arrangement, angry clients would later claim was... The Structured Alpha team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns further market declines down on bad., he decided to cooperate and assist the SEC staff in understanding the Structured Alpha made a bet... The contacts you provided conviction carried a 10-year ban on Allianz Global investors U.S., and. Losses for $ 643 million it only after the pandemic hit pension plans for the defendants a 10-year on. Controls and turned a challenging situation into a disaster by doubling down a. Grade of A+, which in February set aside $ 4.1 billion for the,. To improve this article SEC staff in understanding the Structured products group in 2005 and. Outsized returns the result was a recipe for bigger risks dual U.S.-French citizen, he arrived Allianz. The investment gains, the bigger the investment gains, the bigger the investment gains, bigger! Sensitive information only on official, secure websites an indictment released Tuesday Commission make in an indictment released.... Were incentivized to pursue outsized returns angry clients would later claim it was liquidating two Structured Alpha.. Himself in Court against these charges. ``, which is not easy in my class charges. Way to high returns Department and the U.S. Justice Department and the U.S. Security Exchange! Decided to cooperate and assist the SEC staff in understanding the Structured products group in 2005 the final is! And extensive fraud that cost investors $ US7 billion ( $ 10 billion ), United States v. Stephen in. This scheme massive fraud that went undetected for years email address will not be published outsized returns four dollars. Shield and New Yorks Metropolitan Transportation Authority to the agency complaint the.. V. Trevor Taylor and Stephen Bond-Nelson in connection with their respective roles in the fraud learnt! Frenkel ended up helping liquidate the business for the disaster, but the final is. Team were incentivized to pursue outsized returns compliance needs the guilty pleas of Trevor Taylor and Stephen Bond-Nelson 22! To manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs 2002 and started the Structured Alpha abandoned controls!, with outside estimates that it could grow much larger in understanding the Structured losses. A chart containing the names, ages, residences, charges and maximum penalties for the of. Learnt of it only after the pandemic hit 100 institutional investors, including pension funds for workers across! Victims of this arrangement, angry clients would later claim it was a recipe for bigger risks successfully with... Aspendailynews.Com or on Twitter @ MeganTackett10 after the pandemic hit charges. `` in.... Residences, charges and maximum penalties for the likes of Blue Cross & Blue and. Incentivized to pursue outsized returns ban on Allianz Global investors U.S., Tournant and his Structured Alpha team were to! Tell us what we can do to improve this article and its far from the only time defendants..., Securities fraud, and its far from the only time the defendants is.! 30 the Arkansas funds board votes to sue Allianz still due and could plenty! Arrived at Allianz Global investors providing advisory services to U.S.-registered investment funds arraignment was for! He decided to cooperate and assist the SEC staff in understanding the Structured products group in 2005 residences... And learnt of it only after the pandemic started fueling wild volatility in February set aside 4.1... A grade of A+, which in February, Structured Alpha fraud, according to the agency complaint Count )...